The back story

Bush tea, rum cake and a New Orleans flat white: the Bahamas café back story

In depth: cafés and coffee·The Bahamas

From Cat Island bush tea to Nassau’s first specialty coffee, rum cakes and Eleuthera pineapples.

Coffee at Louis & Steen’s Market Orléans
Coffee at Louis & Steen’s Market Orléans
Photo CreditImage courtesy of © Louis & Steen’s Market Orléans

For generations the Bahamian morning cup came from the garden: leaves of cerasee or guava, brewed as bush tea. The espresso is a newcomer, and the country’s first specialty coffee brand arrived by way of New Orleans. Rum cake, chocolate made from the bean and pineapples from Eleuthera fill the rest of the counter. Why did a nation of tea-brewers and bakers come so late to the café? The answer is mostly in the kitchen.

Before the espresso

The first Bahamian café was a kitchen with a garden outside it. On Cat Island, the tourism ministry tells of three generations of women who treated common ailments with freshly picked bush leaves; today Peggy Johnson brews her bush teas from local plants such as cerasee, breadfruit and guava. The tradition is medicine and hospitality at once, and nobody ever needed a barista for it.

In Nassau, Pasión Tea & Coffee Company carries that tradition onto the shelf, with a range of Bahamian bush teas beside its Caribbean-inspired blends, coffees, spices and hot-pepper tonics. Its founder, Julie Hoffer, calls herself the company’s “tea guru extraordinaire”, and the business is celebrating 21 years, which in a country of coffee newcomers makes it an elder statesman.

The coffee arrives

The espresso came by way of Louisiana. Louis & Steen’s describes itself as the first specialty coffee brand in The Bahamas, pairing its coffee with third-generation Cajun-Creole recipes. Its Market Orléans on Windsor Field Road is a New Orleans-style micro food hall and market, and its Xpresso Bar at RUBiS Gladstone uses Swiss automation that the company calls the first of its kind in the region.

Chives Café & Marketplace shows how the café became a meeting place. Reimagined by its founder, Chef Lise Russell, it now sits in a shady courtyard behind The Shops at Harbour Green, just outside Lyford Cay, serving breakfasts, lunches and take-home meals with a pantry of sauces and marinades. Lemonade is on the house every day, which in this heat counts as diplomacy.

Sugar without cane

The Bahamian sweet tooth runs on rum. Purity Bakery bakes Bacardi Rum Cakes in Nassau in three versions: the original, a piña colada cake and a Nassau Royale chocolate rum cake. On Bay Street, Tortuga Rum Cake Bakery sells its Golden Original and a range of other flavours.

Rum cake even has its own paperwork. At Lynden Pindling International Airport, the tax-free rules set a separate minimum purchase for rum cakes, apart from tobacco and alcohol. The rum cake is the only pastry we know with its own line in the customs rules, which tells you how many leave the country in hand luggage.

The entrance to Chives Café & Marketplace under its shingled roof
The entrance to Chives Café & Marketplace under its shingled roof
Photo CreditImage courtesy of © Chives Café & Marketplace

Graycliff Chocolatier, on the historic Graycliff estate in old Nassau, goes back to the bean. Visitors follow cocoa from roasting and grinding into nibs to stone-ground liquid chocolate poured into moulds, then make their own bar in the classroom; adults can pair the chocolates with rum, whisky or port. It opens daily from 9am to 5pm, except on Christmas Day and New Year’s Day.

The rum cake is the only pastry we know with its own line in the customs rules.

Pineapples and pastries

In the Out Islands the café is closer to the farm. On Eleuthera, between Hatchet Bay and Gregory Town, Eleuthera Pineapple Farm Tours walks visitors through pineapple fields, fruit orchards and vegetable gardens, and its Sugar Loaf Café is the place to stop afterwards. Gregory Town’s Pineapple Festival, a yearly celebration on the official calendar, brings families home to see the harvest on display.

On Harbour Island, Arthur’s Bakery & Restaurant serves breakfast and lunch every day except Sunday, and specialises in breads, danishes, cookies and pastries. It is the kind of place where the queue is the guidebook: if the locals are waiting, the bread is out of the oven.

Why so late to the café?

The answer is that the Bahamian table was always at home, in the hotel or at the fish fry, not on the pavement. Tea came from the yard, cake from the family oven and coffee from the hotel pot. Today’s cafés simply put all three on one counter, and the best of them still taste of the garden as much as the roaster.

Our advice: start a Nassau morning with a coffee at Louis & Steen’s, buy a bush tea from Pasión to take home, book the chocolate class at Graycliff, and on Eleuthera time your visit for the pineapple season.

Why it's on our list

  • Before the espresso
  • The coffee arrives
  • Sugar without cane
  • Pineapples and pastries

Location

The map comes from Google Maps, which sets its own cookies once it loads.

Open in Google Maps

The ULTIMATE letter

The Bahamas in your inbox

An occasional email with new places, island guides and our latest in-depth articles. No spam, ever.