The back story
Rum runners, dollar bills and a bronze foundry: the Bahamas bar back story
Prohibition on Prince George Wharf, Hemingway’s Bimini and the signed dollars of Green Turtle Cay.

During American Prohibition, the colonial government expanded Prince George Wharf in Nassau to cope with the flow of alcohol. The islands have taken drinking seriously ever since, in clubs founded by anglers, a pub papered with dollar bills and a bar beside the only working bronze foundry in the country. Why are the best Bahamian bars on docks rather than high streets? Because almost everyone used to arrive by boat.
A wharf built for whisky
The islands have always had a talent for supplying thirsty neighbours. When the United States banned alcohol, the official tourism history records, the colonial government expanded Prince George Wharf in Nassau to accommodate the flow of liquor; when Prohibition ended, so did the enormous revenues. On Bimini, the Big Game Club says, prosperity came and went just as quickly in the 1920s.
Nassau had a lawless past to live down. By 1718 the King of England had appointed Woodes Rogers royal governor, with the job of restoring order; he offered amnesty to those who surrendered, and some 300 pirates did, while Blackbeard and others fled. The Woodes Rogers Tavern at the British Colonial carries his name, which is more than the pirates got.
Rum without a cane field
John Watling’s Distillery makes its rum on the Buena Vista Estate in downtown Nassau, established in 1789. The Bahamas has no native sugar industry, so the distillery imports molasses and distillates from around the Caribbean and ages and blends them in Nassau. The estate’s guests have included the folk singer Burl Ives, and it was a filming location for the James Bond film Casino Royale.
The islands have also invented their own drinks. John Watling’s credits Uncle Will’s Rum Dum to Wilfred Sands at the Lyford Cay Club in 1971, and the Goombay Smash to Ms Emily Cooper in 1973; the tourism ministry calls Green Turtle Cay the Smash’s birthplace. Both are on the menu at the distillery’s Tavern, where the complimentary tour, like all good history lessons, ends.
The island clubhouses
Bimini’s bar culture began in black tie. The Big Game Club records that Neville Stuart opened the Bimini Big Game Fishing Club in 1936 as a formal dining club, with tuxedo and tie preferred for gentlemen, and that Ernest Hemingway arrived in 1935 and drank, brawled and wrote through several seasons. Black tie on an island where the main road was the sea: Bimini has always known how to make an entrance.
The Bacardi family later bought the club and reopened it in 1972. Today Hemingway’s Poolside Rum Club raises a glass to “Papa” beside the pool with the island’s largest selection of high-end Caribbean rums, while Sharkies Bar & Grill grills conch and lobster by the dock.
Black tie on an island where the main road was the sea: Bimini has always known how to make an entrance.
On Green Turtle Cay, the English biologist Allan Charlesworth bought the land for the Green Turtle Club in 1964. Its pub, The Dollar Bar, is papered with signed dollar bills, a custom the club traces to retired Second World War fighter pilots who pinned up signed bills so that future friends could have a drink on them. The Club’s own punch is the Tipsy Turtle.
At Little Harbour on Great Abaco, settled by the artist Randolph Johnston and his wife Margot in 1951, Pete’s Pub & Gallery stands beside what it calls the only working bronze foundry in The Bahamas. It may be the only bar in the world where the art on the walls was cast a few yards from the beer taps.
Bars you reach by boat
The marina bar is the national institution. The Jib Room at Marsh Harbour Marina takes calls on VHF 16 and pours a Bilge Burner, a Goombay Smash and ice-cold Kalik; Wreckers Restaurant & Bar sits beside the 30-slip marina at Spanish Wells Yacht Haven; and on Little Farmer’s Cay in the Exumas, Ty’s Sunset Bar & Grill has its front door steps from the island’s airstrip.
Our advice: drink the history in order. Start with the tour at John Watling’s in Nassau, take a rum at Hemingway’s on Bimini, sign a dollar at Green Turtle Cay and finish at Pete’s Pub by boat, the way the islands intended.
Why it's on our list
- A wharf built for whisky
- Rum without a cane field
- The island clubhouses
- Bars you reach by boat
Location
The map comes from Google Maps, which sets its own cookies once it loads.
More in depth
The back storyMidnight drums and noon pig roasts: the Bahamas nightlife back storyJunkanoo after midnight, beach bars by boat, lagoon-side casinos and a club with a firm door.