Objects of Desire
A Hemingway Special in Nassau, and other drinks with a Bahamian past
The IBA Hemingway Special, Lyford Cay’s Rum Dum and where Nassau’s best bars pour them.

Photo Credit
Image courtesy of © Rosewood Baha MarHemingway came to Bimini in 1935 for the fishing and stayed several seasons for everything else. The drink that carries his name, rum with grapefruit, maraschino and lime, is now an official IBA classic, and a Nassau distillery makes its own version with Bahamian rum. Why does a country without a sugar industry pour such good rum cocktails? Because it learned to blend, and to drink, with great seriousness.
The recipe
The International Bartenders Association lists the Hemingway Special among its contemporary classics: 60 ml rum, 40 ml grapefruit juice, 15 ml maraschino (Luxardo) and 15 ml fresh lime. Pour everything into a shaker with ice, shake well and strain into a large cocktail glass. There is no garnish, which suits a writer who preferred his sentences without adjectives.
Hemingway’s Bahamian years are well documented. The Bimini Big Game Club records that his friendship with the angler and naturalist Michael Lerner brought him to Bimini in 1935, and that he drank, brawled and wrote his way through several fishing seasons. The official tourism site credits that stay with inspiring The Old Man and the Sea; the bar staff credit it with a great deal of business.
A distillery without a cane field
John Watling’s Distillery, on the Buena Vista Estate in downtown Nassau, makes the case for Bahamian rum. The estate was established in 1789. Since The Bahamas has no native sugar industry, the distillery brings in molasses and pot- and column-still distillates from across the Caribbean, then ages and blends them in Nassau in ex-Bourbon barrels.
The climate does some of the work. About 5% of the rum evaporates each year as the angel’s share, and the distillery says Nassau’s heat speeds up the ageing. Rum cured in heat ages faster, which may be the only thing in the Bahamas that is ever in a hurry. Every bottle carries a hand-woven sisal plait at the neck, made by women’s cooperatives in South Andros or Cat Island.
Its tavern pours its own Hemingway Special, with John Watling’s Pale rum, lime, maraschino and grapefruit, alongside a Bahamian invention: Uncle Will’s Rum Dum, created in 1971 by Wilfred Sands at the Lyford Cay Club, with pale and amber rums, lemon juice and egg white. Tours are complimentary and the estate is open every day except Bahamian holidays.

The Abacos have their own claim to fame. The tourism ministry calls Green Turtle Cay the birthplace of the Goombay Smash, and John Watling’s credits its version to Ms Emily Cooper’s creation of 1973, made with amber rum, coconut rum and pineapple juice. Across the cay, the Green Turtle Club’s pub, papered with signed dollar bills, serves its own Tipsy Turtle rum punch.
Rum cured in heat ages faster, which may be the only thing in the Bahamas that is ever in a hurry.
Where to drink it
For the full grown-up treatment, the Manor Bar at Rosewood Baha Mar is an adults-only room of green velvet stools and a towering back bar, open from noon until midnight, and until 1am on Fridays and Saturdays. Bar Paul at Goldwynn, styled in a sophisticated retro manner, is a lounge by day and a livelier room by night, with crafted cocktails and martinis.
On Bimini, where the story began, Hemingway’s Poolside Rum Club at the Big Game Club invites you to raise a glass to Papa beside the pool, and claims the island’s largest selection of high-end rums from around the Caribbean. It opens from 1pm to 9pm daily, subject to weather and season.
To learn the craft rather than simply enjoy it, book John Watling’s Rum Academy: a guided tasting followed by a mixology class in which you make Bahamian cocktails yourself. Rum flights come in three sizes, Classic, Premium and Prestige, the last ending with the distillery’s Bullion rum. The class is the only one in Nassau where homework is actively encouraged.
The question of sugar
A Hemingway Special is famously sharp, and the IBA recipe has no added sugar at all; the maraschino carries the sweetness. If you prefer it softer, ask the bartender, not the recipe. Purists will wince, but nobody in the islands has ever been refused a drink for liking it sweeter.

Photo Credit
Image courtesy of © Bar PaulOur advice: start at John Watling’s for the tour and a rum flight in the afternoon, then finish at the Manor Bar with the IBA version, made the way the recipe says. Sip it slowly; it was named for a man who did nothing slowly, which is not a reason to copy him.
Why it's on our list
- The recipe
- A distillery without a cane field
- Where to drink it
Location
The map comes from Google Maps, which sets its own cookies once it loads.
More in depth
Objects of DesireLess parked than crouched: the electric Jaguar and the new supercarsJaguar’s Type 00 and Type 01, Ferrari’s first electric car and the record-breakers around them.
Objects of DesireTwin engines, no cars: the beautiful boats of the BahamasMan-O-War’s boatbuilders, Hope Town’s car-free lanes and superyachts at Atlantis Marina.
Objects of DesireCowbells, conch and a carpenter’s saw: how the Bahamas makes musicThe Junkanoo drum, the soldered cowbell and Cat Island’s rake and scrape, and where to hear them.